Spoiler alert: This post includes spoilers from Only Murders in the Developing Season 3, Episode 8.

A person significant top secret at last arrived to mild on Only Murders in the Building, but a blink-and-you are going to-overlook-it depth would seem to be suggesting a stunning new twist to Ben’s authentic identification. In Period 3’s eighth episode, Loretta confirmed a concept that numerous supporters had currently set jointly: she is truly Dickie’s mother. Or is she? Despite the fact that the reveal was definitely a fulfilling twist, a shut examination of Loretta’ bus ticket as proven in the closing credits could flip the script however yet again. Loretta may not be Dickie’s mother, but Ben’s. Here’s why followers believe the two brothers pulled an id swap.

The new principle is that Ben Glenroy, the actor who was murdered, was essentially the older Glenroy brother Dickie, and the human being we know as Dickie has secretly been the genuine Ben all along. This all sprouted from a suspicious day on the bus ticket that Loretta employed when she initially moved to New York to pursue her acting job. The two Loretta and Dickie verified that Ben’s mothers and fathers adopted her son right before they had Ben. However, there’s an challenge with this timeline, due to the fact Loretta stated she gave her infant up for adoption right before she left for New York. Her bus ticket reveals she remaining for NYC in 1976.

But at Ben’s funeral, his start yr was mentioned as 1973.

This does not incorporate up with Loretta’s story, as admirers have been quick to level out on the internet. And the misaligned dates sparked a new idea that Ben may have actually been Loretta’s son. There are a handful of distinctive guesses at how this could have transpired, mostly revolving all over the two brothers swapping identities at some point early in their life. This was previously alluded to when Dickie confessed to Mabel that he was fed up with Ben normally receiving all the credit rating for his operate — this provides a new layer to the idea that he may perhaps have provided his brother his id and been relegated to the background.

If this theory is genuine, then one of the season’s climactic reveals could be that Dickie was truly born Ben Glenroy all along, and the particular person all people imagined was Ben was in fact his older brother Dickie, whom Loretta gave up for adoption. It’s continue to not thoroughly crystal clear how this possible switcheroo may possibly match into the murder plot, but it’s surely likely to transform up some prominent supporter theories about who murdered Ben/Dickie.